© tanaonte stock.adobe.com
A recommendation by ECHA’s socio-economic committee (SEAC) for further use derogations could heavily influence the forthcoming EU PFAS restriction proposal as the file begins its transfer to the European Commission ahead of a formal dossier expected next year.
SEAC’s adoption of its final opinion on 18 November ends the agency's involvement in the preparation of the dossier on which five European authorities began work almost four years ago.
The committee recommended:
- use-specific derogations where justified by the available evidence;
- transition and derogation periods that allow time to develop and implement alternatives and compliance with any additional conditions; and
- time-limited derogations for certain sectors, pending further evaluation.
If the Commission agrees with SEAC’s recommendations, it points to a more industry-friendly restriction that means less disruption to supply chains than the one sought by ECHA’s Committee for Risk Assessment (RAC).
In its final opinion in March, RAC concluded that a full PFAS ban is the most effective way to reduce emissions and exposure – a view that industry has strongly opposed.
SEAC said additional derogations may be required for certain uses "in order for a restriction to be proportionate", but questions remain over what these could be.
SEAC cannot specify such additional derogations because of uncertainties in the available information, the committee said. These mostly concern "a lack of sufficiently granular data, as well as unknown or unidentified uses stemming from the broad scope of the proposed restriction," it added.
SEAC's final opinion "also supports, in principle," the additional risk management measures recommended by RAC to minimise PFAS emissions from derogated uses, ECHA said. However, SEAC concluded that insufficient information was available to assess the costs and benefits of those measures.
Additional sectors
SEAC reiterated its recommendation to evaluate all uses and applications in eight additional sectors as soon as possible. This would be carried out instead of the committee conducting an evaluation.
"In the interim, SEAC recommends a time-limited derogation for all uses/applications within the scope of these specific sectors until such an evaluation has been performed and an appropriate decision can be made on proportionality."
Transition period
There is one notable difference between the draft and final opinions that relates to proposed transition periods.
In its March draft opinion, SEAC said a full PFAS ban with an 18-month transition period, "is likely not proportionate", based on its evaluation of the available information on alternatives, costs and benefits.
In the November opinion, however, it said it finds "the 'default' 18-month transition period to be generally appropriate, while noting uncertainties with respect to uses for which a conclusion on the need for a derogation beyond the 18-month transition period was not possible".
SEAC also said a longer transition period "could be warranted" before reporting requirements, implementation of site-specific PFAS management plans and potential additional conditions take effect.
Next steps
Following adoption, ECHA will finalise the text of SEAC’s opinion to reflect the discussions in this week’s meeting. The agency told Chemical Watch News & Insight that this "will take some weeks".
The agency then will send both committees’ opinions and background documents to the Commission "by the end of the year". At that point, ECHA will make SEAC's comprehensive final opinion public.
The Commission will consider both committee opinions and supporting evidence and formally propose a restriction for discussion and vote in the REACH Committee, which is composed of EU member state representatives.
Ahead of SEAC's opinion adoption, the Netherlands called on several European countries to join it in pushing the Commission for an "ambitious" restriction.
And just days before the ECHA's publication, a key European Court of Auditors (ECA) report claimed the EU’s chemicals framework is ill-equipped to handle PFAS risks, and called for speedy regulatory action on the persistent substances.
