© Philip stock.adobe.com
The US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit has dismissed litigation challenging the EPA's TSCA rule for chrysotile asbestos after concluding that none of the parties seeking changes to the regulation showed that they have standing to bring their claims.
The 19 November ruling leaves intact the agency's 2024 TSCA risk management rule without addressing any of the legal questions raised by the industry, labour and NGO groups that challenged the rule. It also underscores the high burden that parties – and member-based organisations in particular – face in showing they have standing to challenge EPA or other agency rules.
Ryan Schmit, of counsel with Bergeson & Campbell, said the ruling "should serve as a reminder that parties seeking to bring challenges to EPA rules need to provide sufficient evidence upfront to meet this threshold legal requirement" on standing.
In its decision, the Fifth Circuit said none of the parties challenging the rule satisfied their burden of establishing standing, a prerequisite for courts to have jurisdiction over a case. The decision followed sharp questioning from the appellate judges, who voiced skepticism about the parties' standing during oral arguments in the case in June.
"Although the dismissal was not unexpected, it is deeply disappointing," said Linda Reinstein, co-founder and president of the Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization (ADAO), one of the parties in the case.
"ADAO and our public health partners presented compelling scientific and legal arguments, supported by multiple declarations demonstrating our basis for standing. Yet, thirty-five years after the Fifth Circuit overturned most of EPA's 1989 asbestos ban, the same court has once again left critical public health questions unresolved by dismissing the case on standing rather than addressing the merits," she said.
The EPA said it is reviewing the opinion but offered no further comment.
The agency plans to issue a proposed TSCA rule in mid-2027 addressing legacy uses of asbestos following a ‘part 2’ risk evaluation that identified unreasonable risk to human health.
No party showed standing
According to the Fifth Circuit, standing generally requires that a party show they have an injury in fact that is both traceable to the challenged conduct – the TSCA asbestos rule in this case – and likely to be addressed by a favourable ruling from the court.
All the parties in this case relied on associational standing, requiring them to show that their members would independently have standing to sue, among other elements.
The industry petitioners – which included the American Chemistry Council (ACC), the Texas Chemistry Council (TCC) and others – said almost nothing about standing in their opening brief, except that their members "transact business that is directly affected by the final rule", the court said. Instead, they argued that their standing in the case was self-evident, because some members were directly regulated by the asbestos rule.
But the Fifth Circuit said this "self-evident-standing exception" can only apply where the party assumes their standing is evident from the administrative record at the start of the litigation.
The "industry petitioners didn't do that here," the court said. Because they failed to preserve their standing arguments from the start of the case, "those arguments are forfeited", the court said.
The court noted that the ACC asserted standing after oral arguments took place, arguing that it had a right to sue based on the standing of its members, Olin Corporation and Occidental Chemical Corporation, two chlor-alkali producers that are subject to the rule's asbestos restrictions.
However, the ACC failed to show that either company was a member at the time the lawsuit was filed, the court said, adding that Olin also withdrew from the case in May.
The Fifth Circuit dismissed the challenge from the United Steelworkers (USW) union on similar grounds.
According to the court, the labour union mentioned standing "only once, in a footnote" in its opening brief and never provided "concrete evidence" that its members were harmed by shortcomings in the asbestos rule, the court said.
Only the advocacy petitioners – ADAO, the American Public Health Association (APHA) and firefighter union groups – "made any effort to establish standing at the appropriate time", the court said.
But even here, the court said, the parties failed to show that any shortcomings in the asbestos rule would lead to "impeding" or "substantial risk" of harm to their members.
After the ruling, Bob Sussman, who represented the advocacy petitioners, said, "unfortunately, the court seized on jurisdictional obstacles to avoid deciding whether EPA's rule complies" with TSCA.
"The decision leaves unresolved substantial questions about the scope and adequacy of EPA's asbestos protections under TSCA," Sussman said. "We are reviewing the opinion carefully, including its treatment of the petitioners' standing evidence and the available options for further review."
Eyes now turn to Third Circuit and TCE challenge
According to Schmit, with Bergeson & Campbell, by deciding to dismiss the legal challenges to the asbestos rule on standing grounds, the court did not address continued legal questions about the EPA's authority under TSCA to review and manage the risks from existing chemicals.
Just two months before, the Fifth Circuit waded into these issues in its decision in East Fork Enterprises et al v EPA, in which the court vacated a separate TSCA rule on methylene chloride and addressed how the agency should evaluate and regulate existing chemicals under the statute.
Schmit said the asbestos case was "a potential opportunity for the Fifth Circuit to supplement or expand upon its recent views in East Fork". But with the dismissal, he said, the decision "does not provide additional judicial clarity on TSCA legal, policy or scientific issues".
Now, he said, all eyes will be on the Third Circuit and how it may rule in legal challenges to the EPA's TSCA rule for TCE brought by environmental organisations and industry groups.
There are also pending challenges to EPA’s TSCA rules for perchloroethylene (PCE) and carbon tetrachloride (CTC), although both lawsuits remain on hold while the agency reconsiders the underlying regulations.
The Third Circuit case is American Chemistry Council et al v EPA.
The asbestos case in the Fifth Circuit is Texas Chemistry Council v EPA.
